John Schnatter builds a better pizza in a broom closet on October 2, 1984


ZAP! POW! WHAM! A narrative straight out of the Me Decade! The very quintessence of the little man on the make, a veritable Horatio Alger story with a pizza cutter instead of a shoe-shine box! The man, of course, was John Schnatter, and the broom closet—a genuine, honest-to-God broom closet in his father's Jeffersonville, Indiana, tavern!—was his rocket booster. October 2, 1984, the day the secret of all that was pure and good about pizza was revealed not in a high-tech laboratory or a mahogany-paneled corporate boardroom, but amidst the dusty, proletarian detritus of Mick's Lounge. A revelation!

Ah, yes! The broom closet! The ignominious, un-glamorous, wholly un-mythic birthplace of empire! Because, you see, it was never meant to be mythic at first, not with the flickering fluorescent tubes, the smell of Pine-Sol and forgotten mop water, the very banality of its existence. 

Schnatter, all wiry ambition and Indiana grit, stood hunched over a makeshift counter, sweat beading on his brow, his hands kneading dough like a sculptor wrestling clay into immortality. That pizza oven over there? He sold his ’71 Camaro to buy that oven. And there, in that little broom closet, amidst the mops and the buckets and the faint, lingering aroma of cheap beer, he found his secret. And the world, hungry for a piping hot slice of honest, authentic American enterprise, would never be the same again.

He demanded a dough that was fresh, never frozen. The sauce was a symphony of Italian tomatoes, ripened on the vine, crushed with meticulous care, and seasoned with herbs that sang of the Mediterranean sun. And the cheese? 100% real mozzarella.

And the dipping sauce! Another thunderclap! The other guys, those corporate wimps, they never thought to put a little cup of sauce on the side! What kind of an offense to the senses was that?! The man had an epiphany, he had THE DIPPING SAUCE! He knew, he KNEW, that a man's pizza crust, the very soul of the pizza experience, should never be left to fend for itself. What kind of a man would let that happen?!? Not John Schnatter!

The locals at Mick’s who’d never tasted anything fancier than a TV dinner were suddenly poets, waxing rhapsodic about Schnatter's pizza. By the next year, Schnatter was out of the closet—literally—expanding into a proper shop, then franchising, then conquering the pizza cosmos. Papa John’s would become a behemoth, a red-and-green empire built on that broom closet epiphany.

One day decades later, after the woke mob discovered Schnatter's conservative political beliefs and his support for President Donald J. Trump, that empire would oust him. And without John Schnatter, the new Corporate Wimp Papa John's would fall back into third place behind Domino's and Pizza Hut - the very pizza giants Schnatter had aimed to topple with a superior product. Go woke, go broke, as they say. 

But on that chilly October 2nd back in 1984, the pizza world, unbeknownst to itself, had been irrevocably altered. A new titan had kneaded his way onto the scene, armed with nothing but fresh dough, real tomatoes, and an unwavering belief in the power of "Better Ingredients, Better Pizza." John Schnatter didn’t just make pizza. He made America believe in pizza again. ZOOM! BANG! SLICE!

Popular posts from this blog

Apple Hypercard links to the future on August 11, 1987

Members Only jackets give entrée to the 80s' most-exclusive club

Street Fighter establishes a new pugilistic order on August 30, 1987